                                               MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION                               DATE : 07/16/02
                                                                                                                   PAGE : 052 -1
                                                        TABULATION OF BIDS

     CALL ORDER   : 052                     CONTRACT ID : 73021-60138                  COUNTIES : Saginaw County
     LETTING DATE : 07/10/02  10:30 A.M.    REGION      : BAY
                                          CONTRACT TIME : 08/30/02  COMPLETION DATE
     CONTRACT DESCRIPTION :                                                                PROJECT(S) : N/A
     Emergency scour protection measures on M-57 over Deer Creek,
     in the village of Chesaning, Saginaw County.

          SET-ASIDE :

     VENDOR RANKING :

  --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                                                                   TOTAL       % OVER      % OVER
  RANK     VENDOR NO./NAME                                                                          BID         LOW BID     EST
  --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   0    -EST-         ENGINEER'S ESTIMATE                                                    $     43,708.39  115.1764% 100.0000%
   1   08904           J. D. Walt'S, Inc.                                                    $     37,949.10  100.0000%  86.8234%
   2   01392           McDowell Construction , L.L.C.                                        $     39,369.08  103.7418%  90.0721%
   3   04946           Heystek Contracting, Inc.                                             $     44,205.00  116.4850% 101.1362%
   4   00247           E. C. Korneffel Co.                                                   $     49,923.11  131.5528% 114.2186%
   5   02748           Davis Construction, Inc.                                              $     50,821.47  133.9201% 116.2739%
   6   00170           L. W. Lamb, Inc.                                                      $     54,188.00  142.7913% 123.9762%
   7   01851           Posen Construction, Inc.                                              $     56,789.00  149.6452% 129.9270%
   8   02985           Zito Construction                                                     $     64,747.00  170.6154% 148.1340%
====================================================================================================================================
                                          |(   0  ) -EST-              |(   1  ) 08904              |(   2  ) 01392
                                          |ENGINEER'S ESTIMATE         |J. D. Walt'S, Inc.          |McDowell Construction , L.L.C.
LINE NO / ITEM CODE / ALT                 |                            |                            |
ITEM DESCRIPTION            QUANTITY      |  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT
------------------------------------------+----------------------------+----------------------------+-------------------------------
SECTION 0001   BRIDGE
                                          |                            |                            |
0010 1000001                   1.000  LS  |    2000.00000       2000.00|    2000.00000       2000.00|    2000.00000        2000.00
  Mobilization, Max. ____ $2000.00        |                            |                            |
0020 1040001                   1.000  LS  |     800.00000        800.00|    2500.00000       2500.00|     510.00000         510.00
  Contractor Staking                      |                            |                            |
0030 1040005                   5.000  hr  |      75.00000        375.00|       0.01000          0.05|       0.01000           0.05
  Staking Plan Errors and Extras, One     |                            |                            |
  Person                                  |                            |                            |
0040 1040008                   2.000  hr  |     100.00000        200.00|       0.01000          0.02|       0.01000           0.02
  Staking Plan Errors & Extras,Two Person |                            |                            |
0050 1040009                   2.000  hr  |     125.00000        250.00|       0.01000          0.02|       0.01000           0.01
  Staking Plan Errors & Extras, 3 Person  |                            |                            |
0060 2050015                  25.000  m3  |       9.58000        239.50|      75.00000       1875.00|      22.00000         550.00
  Excavation, Earth                       |                            |                            |
0070 4011100                  45.000  m3  |      35.00000       1575.00|      50.00000       2250.00|      40.00000        1800.00
  Culv Bedding                            |                            |                            |
0080 6030130                  38.000  ea  |       9.88388        375.59|      50.00000       1900.00|      30.00000        1140.00
  Lane Tie, Epoxy Anchored                |                            |                            |
0090 7040007                   1.000  LS  |   14000.00000      14000.00|   15939.00000      15939.00|   20000.00000       20000.00
  Cofferdams                              |                            |                            |

                                                                                                                   PAGE : 052 -2
                                                        TABULATION OF BIDS

     CALL ORDER   : 052                     CONTRACT ID : 73021-60138                  COUNTIES : Saginaw County
     LETTING DATE : 07/10/02  10:30 A.M.    REGION      : BAY

          SET-ASIDE :

====================================================================================================================================
                                          |(   0  ) -EST-              |(   1   ) 08904             |(   2  ) 01392
                                          |ENGINEER'S ESTIMATE         |J. D. Walt'S, Inc.          |McDowell Construction , L.L.C.
LINE NO / ITEM CODE / ALT                 |                            |                            |
ITEM DESCRIPTION            QUANTITY      |  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT
------------------------------------------+----------------------------+----------------------------+-------------------------------
0100 7060004                  14.000  m3  |     725.00000      10150.00|     300.00000       4200.00|     500.00000        7000.00
  Conc, Grade S2                          |                            |                            |
0110 7060031                 500.000  kg  |       2.00000       1000.00|       2.00000       1000.00|       2.50000        1250.00
  Reinforcement, Steel, Epoxy Coated      |                            |                            |
0120 8120013                   2.000  ea  |     650.00000       1300.00|     150.00000        300.00|     200.00000         400.00
  Lighted Arrow, Type C, Furn             |                            |                            |
0130 8120014                   2.000  ea  |     150.00000        300.00|      50.00000        100.00|     100.00000         200.00
  Lighted Arrow, Type C, Oper             |                            |                            |
0140 8120026                  30.000  ea  |      16.46000        493.80|       3.00000         90.00|       4.00000         120.00
  Plastic Drum, Lighted, Furn             |                            |                            |
0150 8120027                  25.000  ea  |      13.94000        348.50|       3.00000         75.00|       5.00000         125.00
  Plastic Drum, Lighted, Oper             |                            |                            |
0160 8120054                   1.000  LS  |    2000.00000       2000.00|    1000.00000       1000.00|     500.00000         500.00
  Minor Traf Devices                      |                            |                            |
0170 8120055                   1.000  LS  |    4000.00000       4000.00|       0.01000          0.01|     300.00000         300.00
  Flag Control                            |                            |                            |
0180 8120057                  29.000  m2  |      35.00000       1015.00|      20.00000        580.00|      26.00000         754.00
  Sign, Type B, Temp                      |                            |                            |
0190 8130011                  44.000  m2  |      44.00000       1936.00|      60.00000       2640.00|      55.00000        2420.00
  Riprap, Plain                           |                            |                            |
0200 8167110                 300.000  m2  |       4.50000       1350.00|       5.00000       1500.00|       1.00000         300.00
  _ Slope Restoration-Special             |                            |                            |
     SECTION TOTALS                       |             $     43,708.39|             $     37,949.10|              $     39,369.08
------------------------------------------+----------------------------+----------------------------+-------------------------------
     CONTRACT TOTALS                      |             $     43,708.39|             $     37,949.10|              $     39,369.08
====================================================================================================================================

                                                                                                                   PAGE : 052 -3
                                                        TABULATION OF BIDS

     CALL ORDER   : 052                     CONTRACT ID : 73021-60138                  COUNTIES : Saginaw County
     LETTING DATE : 07/10/02  10:30 A.M.    REGION      : BAY

          SET-ASIDE :

====================================================================================================================================
                                          |(   3  ) 04946              |(   4   ) 00247             |(   5  ) 02748
                                          |Heystek  Contracting Inc.   |E. C. Korneffel Co.         |Davis Construction, Inc.
LINE NO / ITEM CODE / ALT                 |                            |                            |
ITEM DESCRIPTION            QUANTITY      |  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT
------------------------------------------+----------------------------+----------------------------+-------------------------------
SECTION 0001   BRIDGE
                                          |                            |                            |
0010 1000001                   1.000  LS  |    2000.00000       2000.00|    2000.00000       2000.00|    2000.00000        2000.00
  Mobilization, Max. ____ $2000.00        |                            |                            |
0020 1040001                   1.000  LS  |    1000.00000       1000.00|       0.01000          0.01|    2970.00000        2970.00
  Contractor Staking                      |                            |                            |
0030 1040005                   5.000  hr  |       1.00000          5.00|       0.01000          0.05|       0.01000           0.05
  Staking Plan Errors and Extras, One     |                            |                            |
  Person                                  |                            |                            |
0040 1040008                   2.000  hr  |       2.00000          4.00|       0.01000          0.02|     110.00000         220.00
  Staking Plan Errors & Extras,Two Person |                            |                            |
0050 1040009                   2.000  hr  |       3.00000          6.00|       0.01000          0.02|       0.01000           0.02
  Staking Plan Errors & Extras, 3 Person  |                            |                            |
0060 2050015                  25.000  m3  |      10.00000        250.00|      40.00000       1000.00|     307.00000        7675.00
  Excavation, Earth                       |                            |                            |
0070 4011100                  45.000  m3  |      70.00000       3150.00|      40.00000       1800.00|      30.00000        1350.00
  Culv Bedding                            |                            |                            |
0080 6030130                  38.000  ea  |      40.00000       1520.00|      12.50000        475.00|      25.00000         950.00
  Lane Tie, Epoxy Anchored                |                            |                            |
0090 7040007                   1.000  LS  |   15000.00000      15000.00|   25000.00000      25000.00|   12150.00000       12150.00
  Cofferdams                              |                            |                            |
0100 7060004                  14.000  m3  |    1000.00000      14000.00|    1000.00000      14000.00|     857.00000       11998.00
  Conc, Grade S2                          |                            |                            |
0110 7060031                 500.000  kg  |       2.00000       1000.00|       2.00000       1000.00|       0.00000           0.00
  Reinforcement, Steel, Epoxy Coated      |                            |                            |
0120 8120013                   2.000  ea  |      70.00000        140.00|     115.00000        230.00|     124.30000         248.60
  Lighted Arrow, Type C, Furn             |                            |                            |
0130 8120014                   2.000  ea  |      10.00000         20.00|       1.00000          2.00|       1.10000           2.20
  Lighted Arrow, Type C, Oper             |                            |                            |
0140 8120026                  30.000  ea  |       2.00000         60.00|       2.50000         75.00|       2.75000          82.50
  Plastic Drum, Lighted, Furn             |                            |                            |
0150 8120027                  25.000  ea  |       2.00000         50.00|       2.50000         62.50|       2.75000          68.75
  Plastic Drum, Lighted, Oper             |                            |                            |
0160 8120054                   1.000  LS  |     200.00000        200.00|     100.00000        100.00|    3000.00000        3000.00
  Minor Traf Devices                      |                            |                            |
0170 8120055                   1.000  LS  |     200.00000        200.00|       0.01000          0.01|    3000.00000        3000.00
  Flag Control                            |                            |                            |
0180 8120057                  29.000  m2  |      40.00000       1160.00|      16.50000        478.50|      18.15000         526.35
  Sign, Type B, Temp                      |                            |                            |

                                                                                                                   PAGE : 052 -4
                                                        TABULATION OF BIDS

     CALL ORDER   : 052                     CONTRACT ID : 73021-60138                  COUNTIES : Saginaw County
     LETTING DATE : 07/10/02  10:30 A.M.    REGION      : BAY

          SET-ASIDE :

====================================================================================================================================
                                          |(   3  ) 04946              |(   4   ) 00247             |(   5  ) 02748
                                          |Heystek  Contracting Inc.   |E. C. Korneffel Co.         |Davis Construction, Inc.
LINE NO / ITEM CODE / ALT                 |                            |                            |
ITEM DESCRIPTION            QUANTITY      |  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT
------------------------------------------+----------------------------+----------------------------+-------------------------------
0190 8130011                  44.000  m2  |      60.00000       2640.00|      50.00000       2200.00|      70.00000        3080.00
  Riprap, Plain                           |                            |                            |
0200 8167110                 300.000  m2  |       6.00000       1800.00|       5.00000       1500.00|       5.00000        1500.00
  _ Slope Restoration-Special             |                            |                            |
     SECTION TOTALS                       |             $     44,205.00|             $     49,923.11|              $     50,821.47
------------------------------------------+----------------------------+----------------------------+-------------------------------
     CONTRACT TOTALS                      |             $     44,205.00|             $     49,923.11|              $     50,821.47
====================================================================================================================================

                                                                                                                   PAGE : 052 -5
                                                        TABULATION OF BIDS

     CALL ORDER   : 052                     CONTRACT ID : 73021-60138                  COUNTIES : Saginaw County
     LETTING DATE : 07/10/02  10:30 A.M.    REGION      : BAY

          SET-ASIDE :

====================================================================================================================================
                                          |(   6  ) 00170              |(   7   ) 01851             |(   8  ) 02985
                                          |L. W. Lamb, Inc.            |Posen Construction, Inc.    |Zito Construction
LINE NO / ITEM CODE / ALT                 |                            |                            |
ITEM DESCRIPTION            QUANTITY      |  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT
------------------------------------------+----------------------------+----------------------------+-------------------------------
SECTION 0001   BRIDGE
                                          |                            |                            |
0010 1000001                   1.000  LS  |    2000.00000       2000.00|    2000.00000       2000.00|    2000.00000        2000.00
  Mobilization, Max. ____ $2000.00        |                            |                            |
0020 1040001                   1.000  LS  |    1000.00000       1000.00|    2700.00000       2700.00|    6000.00000        6000.00
  Contractor Staking                      |                            |                            |
0030 1040005                   5.000  hr  |      20.00000        100.00|       1.00000          5.00|      75.00000         375.00
  Staking Plan Errors and Extras, One     |                            |                            |
  Person                                  |                            |                            |
0040 1040008                   2.000  hr  |      30.00000         60.00|     100.00000        200.00|     100.00000         200.00
  Staking Plan Errors & Extras,Two Person |                            |                            |
0050 1040009                   2.000  hr  |      60.00000        120.00|       1.00000          2.00|       1.00000           2.00
  Staking Plan Errors & Extras, 3 Person  |                            |                            |
0060 2050015                  25.000  m3  |     100.00000       2500.00|     100.00000       2500.00|     100.00000        2500.00
  Excavation, Earth                       |                            |                            |
0070 4011100                  45.000  m3  |      60.00000       2700.00|      60.00000       2700.00|      85.00000        3825.00
  Culv Bedding                            |                            |                            |
0080 6030130                  38.000  ea  |      50.00000       1900.00|       8.50000        323.00|      50.00000        1900.00
  Lane Tie, Epoxy Anchored                |                            |                            |
0090 7040007                   1.000  LS  |   12000.00000      12000.00|   17000.00000      17000.00|   20000.00000       20000.00
  Cofferdams                              |                            |                            |
0100 7060004                  14.000  m3  |    1400.00000      19600.00|    1000.00000      14000.00|     695.00000        9730.00
  Conc, Grade S2                          |                            |                            |
0110 7060031                 500.000  kg  |       3.00000       1500.00|      10.00000       5000.00|       4.00000        2000.00
  Reinforcement, Steel, Epoxy Coated      |                            |                            |
0120 8120013                   2.000  ea  |     125.00000        250.00|     200.00000        400.00|     200.00000         400.00
  Lighted Arrow, Type C, Furn             |                            |                            |
0130 8120014                   2.000  ea  |       1.00000          2.00|     100.00000        200.00|     200.00000         400.00
  Lighted Arrow, Type C, Oper             |                            |                            |
0140 8120026                  30.000  ea  |       2.50000         75.00|       4.00000        120.00|       5.00000         150.00
  Plastic Drum, Lighted, Furn             |                            |                            |
0150 8120027                  25.000  ea  |       2.50000         62.50|       5.00000        125.00|       5.00000         125.00
  Plastic Drum, Lighted, Oper             |                            |                            |
0160 8120054                   1.000  LS  |    5000.00000       5000.00|    5000.00000       5000.00|    4500.00000        4500.00
  Minor Traf Devices                      |                            |                            |
0170 8120055                   1.000  LS  |    1000.00000       1000.00|     500.00000        500.00|    4500.00000        4500.00
  Flag Control                            |                            |                            |
0180 8120057                  29.000  m2  |      16.50000        478.50|      26.00000        754.00|      20.00000         580.00
  Sign, Type B, Temp                      |                            |                            |

                                                                                                                   PAGE : 052 -6
                                                        TABULATION OF BIDS

     CALL ORDER   : 052                     CONTRACT ID : 73021-60138                  COUNTIES : Saginaw County
     LETTING DATE : 07/10/02  10:30 A.M.    REGION      : BAY

          SET-ASIDE :

====================================================================================================================================
                                          |(   6  ) 00170              |(   7   ) 01851             |(   8  ) 02985
                                          |L. W. Lamb, Inc.            |Posen Construction, Inc.    |Zito Construction
LINE NO / ITEM CODE / ALT                 |                            |                            |
ITEM DESCRIPTION            QUANTITY      |  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT|  UNIT PRICE          AMOUNT
------------------------------------------+----------------------------+----------------------------+-------------------------------
0190 8130011                  44.000  m2  |      60.00000       2640.00|      40.00000       1760.00|      65.00000        2860.00
  Riprap, Plain                           |                            |                            |
0200 8167110                 300.000  m2  |       4.00000       1200.00|       5.00000       1500.00|       9.00000        2700.00
  _ Slope Restoration-Special             |                            |                            |
     SECTION TOTALS                       |             $     54,188.00|             $     56,789.00|              $     64,747.00
------------------------------------------+----------------------------+----------------------------+-------------------------------
     CONTRACT TOTALS                      |             $     54,188.00|             $     56,789.00|              $     64,747.00
====================================================================================================================================

